A TikTok from the channel Tech Unlocked, dated 14 August and viewed on 29 September 2026, carries the title "Windows 12 is Here: Why I'm NOT Upgrading (And you shouldn't either)". When I looked it had 1,911 likes, 209 comments, 826 saves and 412 shares.
Microsoft has not announced Windows 12. It has not dated it, priced it or specified its hardware. When a report claiming a modular, AI-first, subscription Windows 12 for 2026 went round in March, Windows Central's Zac Bowden said his contacts confirmed there was no such plan, and suggested the report was either AI generated or AI researched, published without much fact checking. Windows Latest reached the same conclusion. The story still collected over 12,000 upvotes on Reddit.
It travelled because people no longer trust Microsoft to do the sensible thing. After a run of pulled updates, emergency patches and forced features, a fake successor that demands new hardware sounded entirely plausible. That is the real finding. The rumour is fiction. The plausibility is earned.
Meanwhile, the thing that is real has a date on it.
Windows 10 support ended on 14 October 2025. Microsoft sells a bridge called Extended Security Updates, and it is security patches only: no fixes, no features, no support.
For organisations the price is $61 per device in the first year, $122 in the second and $244 in the third. That is $427 per machine over three years for the privilege of not being hacked through a hole Microsoft has stopped fixing for free.
The year one window closes on 13 October 2026. After that date, a device without a year two licence gets no further Windows 10 security updates.
Home users have it easier. Microsoft's own page lists three routes: free if you sync your PC settings to a Microsoft account, 1,000 Rewards points, or a one-time $30 (or local currency equivalent). All three cover updates through 12 October 2027. The consumer scheme is not offered for domain-joined or MDM-managed devices, so it is no answer for an office. Microsoft also says enrolment options and timing vary by region, such as the EEA, so check your own account before you advise anyone.
The doubling is not an accident. Windows 7's extended support started at $25 a PC and eventually quadrupled to $100, according to Canalys. When the NHS negotiated extended support for Windows XP in 2014, the fees The Register reported started at $200 a desktop and rose to $400 and then $800. The Register reported that the high price was fixed deliberately, to stop customers dawdling. It is a stick, designed to be one.
The rule that surprises finance teams is that ESU purchases are cumulative. An organisation that enrols for the first time in year two must also pay for year one. That is $183 per device rather than $122.
So waiting saves nothing. You pay the same total and you spend a year without patches. The maths below is my own arithmetic on commercial list prices, in dollars. It is illustrative, not a quote, and partner discounts will change it.
250 devices
| Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Cumulative | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Whole fleet | $15,250 | $30,500 | $61,000 | $106,750 |
| 30% stuck (75 devices) | $4,575 | $9,150 | $18,300 | $32,025 |
2,000 devices
| Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Cumulative | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Whole fleet | $122,000 | $244,000 | $488,000 | $854,000 |
| 30% stuck (600 devices) | $36,600 | $73,200 | $146,400 | $256,200 |
Only machines that cannot move to Windows 11 need ESU, so the second row in each table is the realistic one for most estates. Even so, year three costs four times year one, and more than years one and two combined. It buys no asset. It arrives mid-financial-year for many firms as an unbudgeted variance. And the decision that caused it was made in Redmond, not in your boardroom.
Windows 11 requires a TPM 2.0 module, UEFI and Secure Boot, among other things. Microsoft has said it will not relax them. A PC that fails the check is not broken. It ran Windows 10 perfectly well yesterday. It has been declared obsolete by a specification change.
Canalys forecast in 2023 that around 240 million PCs, roughly a fifth of Windows 10 devices, would become e-waste, because incompatibility destroys their value for refurbishment. A waste industry model used a figure of 400 million incompatible devices. Neither is a count, and the gap between them shows how thin the data is. But the direction is clear: a great deal of working hardware is being written off by a vendor.
Workarounds exist and reportedly still work on 25H2. But an unsupported install shows a watermark and may not receive updates, and running outside supported configuration is a hard thing to defend in an audit. For any firm chasing Cyber Essentials, "may not receive updates" is not a hack. It is a finding. IASME's guidance is explicit: since 14 October 2025, in-scope Windows 10 devices that are not enrolled in ESU count as unsupported and non-compliant, while enrolled devices remain compliant. By that logic, a device that lapses out of ESU on 13 October drops out of compliance on the same day.
Governments are the best evidence in this story, because they publish contracts and answer questions.
The Isle of Man. In November 2025 iomtoday reported that the Isle of Man Government was paying £239,800 for extended support, which a Cabinet Office spokesperson described as the total cost and said was based on the standard Microsoft licence fee. It keeps Windows 10 devices receiving security updates while they are upgraded. At that point 32% of the estate ran Windows 11, with completion promised by October 2026. The Cabinet Office said it was incorrect to claim the government was no longer receiving security updates, and pointed to Manx Care, whose complex integrated systems take time to upgrade and test.
That promise is now due. The record does not say how many devices the £239,800 covers, whether it is one year or the whole agreement, or what the next year will cost if the deadline slips. Those are fair Freedom of Information questions.
UK central government. A Find a Tender notice shows the Mining Remediation Authority bought Windows 10 and Exchange Server extended support for one year, 15 October 2025 to 14 October 2026, at £35,015.41 excluding VAT. That term expires the day after year one closes. If the list price pattern holds, the renewal is at double. That last point is my inference, not the notice's.
One number to handle with care: Defra spent £312 million on IT modernisation over its 2022-23 to 2024-25 spending period, a programme that included removing 31,500 Windows 7 laptops. Its first letter to MPs said they had moved to Windows 10. Defra later corrected that, and its permanent secretary wrote that all laptops were on Windows 11 by March 2025. It is tempting to divide one number by the other. Don't. It was not an ESU cost, and the programme also covered other work such as application migration and moving services to private cloud. The Register reported that Defra still had 24,000 end-of-life devices.
Continental Europe is heading somewhere else entirely. Schleswig-Holstein is moving around 30,000 workstations away from Microsoft. About 80% now run LibreOffice, email has moved to open-source tools, and the state reports more than €15 million in licence savings against a planned €9 million investment this year. The Linux desktop comes last, deliberately.
France's digital directorate, DINUM, announced in April 2026 that it would move its own workstations to Linux and told every ministry to produce a plan for reducing dependence on non-European technology by autumn. Some outlets have reported 2.5 million workstations, but the more careful coverage describes a directorate-level move and a planning mandate, so treat the larger figure as unconfirmed. Early reports also said Denmark was dropping Windows for Linux. Later reporting clarified that the confirmed ministry move was from Microsoft Office to LibreOffice.
One caution from the more sober coverage: migrating because a licence is free can end up costing more if applications must be rebuilt and staff retrained. Open source is not a discount code.
Buy ESU. Fastest and cheapest in year one, and the right tool for a bounded migration with an end date. Wrong as a destination, because the price doubles and the stop date is 10 October 2028.
Upgrade in place. Free on eligible machines and the right first move for every device that qualifies. The destination is not risk-free: Windows 11 has its own reliability record, as the September 2026 patching problems showed. The Sovereign Auditor covered it in Patched On Time Is Not the Same as Patched Safely.
Replace hardware. Clean and supported, but capital spend pulled forward by a vendor's specification change, and a contribution to the e-waste pile. Best for machines already near the end of their useful life, where ESU money would be better spent on the replacement.
Run unsupported. Zero cash cost and the highest risk. It only makes sense for genuinely isolated devices, documented as an accepted risk.
A Cloud PC. Microsoft lists Windows 365 as an option: Windows 11 delivered to any device, with old hardware as a thin client. It also means a recurring subscription and deeper dependence on the same vendor.
Linux. Extends the life of hardware Microsoft has written off, with no licence fee and real control. It needs skills many small firms lack, and line-of-business software is often Windows-bound.
macOS. A strong managed-device story and a clean break, at the cost of buying Apple hardware and retraining staff.
There is a simple decision rule. Replace a device when its net replacement cost, after resale or trade-in, is lower than the cumulative ESU cost for the years you would actually need it, plus the cost of the risk in the gap.
There is another deadline hiding behind the first. Microsoft's original 2011 Secure Boot certificates began expiring in June 2026. Microsoft says devices without the newer 2023 certificates keep booting and keep installing standard updates, but they can no longer receive new protections for the early boot process, including boot manager updates and revocation lists.
Some commentary claims unpatched machines will fail to boot. Microsoft's own page does not say that. The accurate claim is loss of future boot-level protection. Overstating it only hands critics an easy correction. But reports indicate the certificate rollout is limited to machines still in the update pipeline, which for most Windows 10 devices means ESU. That is another reason not to leave a machine outside it by accident.
One more cost belongs in the table. In January 2026 Microsoft confirmed to Forbes that it gave the FBI BitLocker recovery keys for three laptops under a search warrant in a 2025 Guam investigation, and said it receives about 20 such requests a year. Where a recovery key sits in the user's Microsoft cloud account, Microsoft can be compelled to hand it over. Where the customer stores it locally, it cannot.
That is not proof that Windows 11 is uniquely exposed. It shows that the default account-based setup moves key custody to the vendor. For any organisation that treats jurisdiction as a control, that decision belongs beside the licence price.
The uncomfortable summary for a finance director is that every option costs money, the cheapest-looking one gets more expensive each year, and the decision was made by someone else. The only choice that is still yours is whether you make it on purpose.
Figures marked as my own arithmetic use commercial list prices in US dollars and exclude partner discounts. Check sterling pricing with a licensing partner before budgeting. The full evidence trail, with each claim graded by source quality, is available on request.
The Sovereign Auditor covers digital sovereignty, cybersecurity governance, and data protection policy, with particular focus on Isle of Man jurisdiction and Crown Dependency issues.
Payments via PayPal. Credentials delivered by email. No Substack. No Stripe. No middlemen.